← Back to the worked example

Customer workspace · sample data

See every car the way a careful buyer would.

Carl keeps one connected picture of the model, official record, advert, seller evidence, physical car and deal—then shows why the candidates differ.

Safe to exploreThis is a permanent preview. Nothing here is a live advert or saved to an account.
Search picture3 different stories · 1 currently holds together

The front-runner is the car whose price, history and condition make the most coherent case. Every material open question stays visible.

Selected advert

2019 Toyota Corolla 1.8 Hybrid Icon

Automatic · petrol hybrid · dealer advert

Picture holds together
Asking price
£13,450
Mileage
48,200 miles
Seller
Independent dealer
Registration
AA19 CAR

Carl’s experienced read

The picture mostly holds together

Nothing in the evidence currently breaks the car’s story, but the physical car still has to prove it.

Living picture
Why it stands out
The asking price sits close to the middle of the matched advert sample.18 matched adverts; middle range £12,875–£13,995; high confidence
Does this car’s story hold?
3 official MOT testsThe advert identity and recorded mileage agree with the official record. Service history is claimed, but the advert does not show its format or coverage.
What cars like this make important
Lower non-pass rate than its baseline11.2% did not pass on first presentation; 6,482 eligible DVSA tests. The leading recorded attention areas are brakes.
What could still change the picture
A thin service record would make a normal asking price less attractive.An answer is useful only when it changes confidence, likely cost or whether the journey is worthwhile. Silence is not proof.
Best move from here
Get the service-history summary, then take the hybrid and tyre checks to the car.Carl carries what you learn into the viewing and, when the evidence supports it, the offer and walk-away point.
Observed in this model-year cohort1 MOT attention area to prioritise at the viewing

Brakes

3.7% of eligible first-presentation tests recorded this finding; 242 tests

At the viewing: Inspect the brakes items named in the viewing plan and record any concern.

Population evidence is not a diagnosis or a 12–36 month fault forecast. It tells you where to look more closely; this car still needs a physical inspection.

Shortest useful first message

“Hi, I’m interested in the Corolla. What form of service history comes with it, and which years and mileages does it cover? If available, could you also share the latest hybrid health-check result? Thanks.”

What an experienced buyer would do nextGet the service-history summary, then take the hybrid and tyre checks to the car.

Check one of my adverts

Side-by-side

Compare the stories, not a row of scores.

The front-runner can change when the seller replies or the viewing adds evidence. Price matters only after history, condition and likely spend are connected.

Story currently holds best

Candidate 1

2019 Toyota Corolla 1.8 Hybrid Icon

£13,450
Why it leads
Price, identity and mileage tell a coherent story
Open point
Service-history coverage is not visible
At the car
Hybrid operation, brake transition and tyres
Deal logic
Near-median money needs near-median condition

Candidate 2

2020 Ford Focus 1.0 EcoBoost Titanium

£11,995
Why it is in play
Below-median price and a coherent mileage trail
Open point
Maintenance coverage is too vague for this engine
At the car
Cold start, tyre advisory and clutch behaviour
Deal logic
The saving must survive overdue work and tyres

Candidate 3

2018 Vauxhall Grandland X 1.2 Elite Nav

£9,750
Why it looked tempting
Low asking price from a private seller
What breaks the story
Official mileage falls between consecutive tests
What would change it
Matching reg and current odometer evidence
Deal logic
A discount cannot price an unexplained identity conflict

Your search will look different

Start with the advert you are considering now.

Check a car free